Report to: Development Services Committee Date of Meeting:
SUBJECT: RECOMMENDATION REPORT
Miller Paving Limited
Draft Plan of
FILES: SU.06-105672 and ZA.04-017225
PREPARED BY: Teema Kanji, Senior Planner, extension 4480
Central District
RECOMMENDATION:
That the report dated December 12,
2006 entitled “Miller Paving Limited, 7781 Woodbine Avenue, Application for
Draft Plan of
That the record of the Public
Meeting held on
That staff be authorized to schedule a Public Meeting to consider an official plan amendment to designate 11.9 ha (29.4 acres) of the subject property from INDUSTRIAL to INDUSTRIAL – General Industrial, in order to confirm the intended sub-category of Industrial use in the Official Plan;
That draft plan of subdivision 19TM-06001 located on the east side of Woodbine Avenue, north of 14th Avenue, proposed by Miller Paving Limited, be draft approved subject to the “red line” revisions and conditions outlined in Appendix ‘A’;
That the applications to amend Zoning By-laws 2284-68 and 177-96 be approved and the implementing Zoning By-laws set out in Appendix ‘B’ be finalized and enacted;
That the Chief Administrative Officer and the Commissioner, Community and Fire Services, report back to the Council regarding the details of the terms and conditions of a Purchase and Sale Agreement with respect to land exchange/sale between the Town and Miller Paving Ltd.;
That the Purchase and Sale Agreement between the Town and Miller Paving Ltd is to be executed prior any final approval of the plan of subdivision for registration;
That the required Phasing Agreement and Environmental Management Plan shall address the timing of development, infrastructure, site remediation, and decommissioning and relocation of the existing Miller Paving operation, to the satisfaction of the Town;
That the applicant provide to the Town the required payment of 30% subdivision processing fees in accordance with the Town’s Fee By-law (By-law 2005-357); and
That the draft plan of subdivision approval shall lapse after a period of three years, commencing on December 19, 2006, unless extended by the Town upon application by the Owner.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
The 29.4 ha (72.7 acre) site is located east of
In 2005, Council approved an Official Plan Amendment (
The property was originally used for sand and gravel extraction from the 1950’s to 1970’s and landfill was deposited on the property in the late 1970’s. The site is identified by the Ministry of the Environment (MOE), and in the Markham Official Plan, as a “Former Waste Disposal Site”. MOE has advised that the Minister’s approval (Section 46, Environmental Protection Act) for use of lands is not required because landfilling or waste disposal activities occurred on the property over 25 years ago. In accordance with the requirements of the MOE and the Town’s official plan policies, the applicant must submit a number of environmental reports (i.e. Phase II Environmental Site Assessment, Remediation Plan, etc.) to demonstrate that the environmental conditions of the site are suitable for the proposed commercial/industrial uses. These requirements have been included in the draft plan conditions (Appendix A).
A Master Servicing Study prepared for the development of the
subject lands has identified Town owned lands on the east side of
The redevelopment of the Miller site and corresponding
property requirements on Town property (storm pond and Street ‘A’) will have an
impact on the existing Town Maintenance Yard Operations. The Operations Department recently initiated
a two-phase Public Works Facility Master Plan Study, to review the existing
facility portfolio and identify goals and objectives to be pursued over the
next 20 years. One
option recommends a site of approximately 10 ha (25 acres) in the future, in
the vicinity of the Town’s existing yard maintenance operations [4.5 ha (11.1
acres)] on the west side of
The applicant requires 0.37 ha (0.92 acres) from
the Town to construct an east/west road connecting
The subject plan of subdivision is to be revised to show a location for the storm pond on the subject lands, pending the applicant reaching agreement with the Town to locate a pond on Town owned lands. Any registration of the easterly industrial parcels on the plan of subdivision will likewise be dependent on the applicant reaching agreement with the Town on the proposed extension of Street ‘A’ through the Town owned lands. In the event that agreement cannot be reached, the final plan (road pattern and lotting) is to be revised to the satisfaction of the Town.
As directed by Council on
It is recommended that a formal Agreement of Purchase and
Statutory public meetings were held on
FINANCIAL CONSIDERATIONS:
Not applicable at this time. Staff is to report back on the terms and
conditions of an Agreement of Purchase and
The subject lands consist of approximately 29.4
hectares located east of
The northeast portion of the property currently
supports an office and garage complex, asphalt plant, and roller maintenance
facility, asphalt testing lab, and refuelling areas by Miller Paving Limited. A bus washing facility and a waste transfer
facility are located north of
The subject property is bounded to the north by a
Hydro Corridor and lands being protected by the Province for a proposed future
Highway 407 transitway, and further north by lands owned by Magna International
and Highway 407 (Figure 3). To the south
is an existing gas station located at the northeast corner of Woodbine and 14th
Avenues and further south across
Proposal
to develop lands for commercial/industrial uses
The applicant is proposing to develop the west
portion of the property with Major Commercial and Business Corridor uses (17.5
hectares) and the east portion of the property with industrial uses (9.7
hectares). A number of new roadways are
proposed as part of the plan of subdivision.
Proposed
plan of subdivision
The subject lands are proposed to be subdivided
into twelve blocks to accommodate commercial and industrial uses as identified
in the table below.
Proposed
Use |
Block Number |
Hectares |
Acres |
Major Commercial |
Block 2 |
15.3 |
37.9 |
Business Corridor |
Block 1 |
2.1 |
5.2 |
General Industrial |
Blocks 4,5, 9 to 11 |
0.6 to 1.0 |
1.5 to 2.5 |
General Industrial |
Blocks 3, |
> 1.0 |
> 2.5 |
Roads |
|
2.3 |
5.6 |
Total |
|
29.4 |
72.7 |
Block 1 fronts onto
The plan also provides for lands to complete an
east/west collector road (Street ‘A’) connecting
Official
Plan Amendment required to designate lands to General Industrial
In 2003, Council adopted Official
Plan Amendment 112 to redesignate the lands from Parkway Belt West to
Industrial. The Official Plan also
identifies a former Waste Disposal Site symbol at the southwest corner of the
property, and provides that the Ministry of the Environment (MOE) confirm that
the development satisfies the Environmental Protection Act and that various
studies and mitigative measures are completed, to the satisfaction of the MOE and
the Town. Environmental issues are discussed in greater detail below.
In 2005, the applicant applied for
an official plan amendment to permit a large format shopping centre and office
uses on approximately 20.47 ha (50.5 acres) of their lands, primarily
contiguous to the Woodbine Avenue and Miller Road frontages. Miller’s
total land holding at the time was approximately 35.6 ha (87.9 acres), and
included 6.2 ha of lands which were subsequently severed to create a site for a
new waste transfer station, adjacent to
In 2006 the applicant applied for a
draft plan of subdivision to create the commercial parcels (17.5 ha) on
Woodbine, and to create industrial parcels on the additional developable lands to
the east (11.9 ha). The proposed
industrial parcels which form part of the draft plan of subdivision, while
designated INDUSTRIAL through
Zoning by-law
prepared for subject lands
The subject lands are zoned
Industrial Four (M4) by By-law 2284-68, as amended (Figure 2). The M4 zone permits a range of industrial and
limited commercial uses. A zoning by-law
amendment is required to permit the proposed major commercial and business
corridor uses, as well as to update the industrial use categories for the
remainder of the site. The applicant has
not provided a conceptual site plan for the site. The zoning by-law has been drafted
incorporating development standards applied to other recently approved large
format shopping centres such as the commercial development at
The zoning by-law contains Hold (H)
provisions as identified in
·
A subdivision agreement is executed;
·
Necessary infrastructure is in place to service the lands including an
acceptable location for a stormwater management pond;
·
Lands required for rights-of-way, etc. have been secured;
·
Lands can be served adequately by the existing commercial transportation
network;
·
Any contamination will be remediated, to the satisfaction of the Town;
·
Any existing or potential off-site contamination has been addressed to
the satisfaction of the Ministry of the Environment and the Town;
·
An area specific Development Charge By-law is enacted;
·
Developers Group or alternative agreement is in place to address costs
of development not dealt with under the Development Charge By-law; and
·
A site plan for the commercial lands has been endorsed.
These Hold (H) provisions will also
be applied to the industrial lands not
covered by
OPTIONS/DISCUSSION:
Town owned
lands identified as preferred location for stormwater management pond
Currently, the stormwater on the site partially
drains to the pond at the location of the former aggregate pit. This will continue on a temporary basis until
the permanent stormwater pond is constructed (currently proposed by the
applicant in 2007). The pond will then
be filled and incorporated as development lands within the draft plan of
subdivision.
The Miller Group has prepared a Master Servicing
Study (February 2006) for the Highway 407/Rodick Road Employment Lands which
captures a total land area of approximately 89.4 ha (220.9 acres). The Study
proposes a location for this new stormwater management facility on Town owned
lands east of
It is recommended that the plan be “red line”
revised to show a storm pond location within the plan of subdivision, pending
the outcome of negotiations between the applicant and the Town in regard to the
applicant’s proposal to locate the storm pond on Town owned lands east of
If the Town cannot be appropriately compensated or
alternatively, an appropriate property exchange between the Town and Miller
Paving Limited cannot be negotiated then the
draft plan of subdivision to be registered, and the Master Environmental
Servicing Plan, will have to be revised to include an on-site stormwater
management pond within the proposed draft plan of subdivision, to the
satisfaction of the Director of Engineering (Appendix A). Interim and long term solutions to
address the impact of the Miller plan on Town lands, and the Town’s maintenance
yard requirements in this area, are under negotiation between the parties. It is recommended that a formal Agreement of
Purchase and
Lands required from
the Town and Ontario Realty Corporation to complete Streets ‘A’, ‘B’ and ‘C’
Street ‘A’
Official Plan Amendment 146 (
Streets ‘B’ and ‘C’
OPA
146 identifies a north-south public road (Street ‘B’) linking the east west
collector road (Street ‘A’) to
The
applicant’s draft phasing plan (to be finalized to the satisfaction of the
Town) indicates that Street ‘B’ is to be constructed from Street ‘A’ to Miller
Avenue in 2007, in order to be in place to provide additional road network to
service the Commercial lands on Woodbine Avenue.
The
final road pattern within the Industrial section of the plan of subdivision
will depend in part on the outcome of the negotiations between the applicant and
the Town with respect to the Town possibly acquiring lands within the Miller draft
plan of subdivision. In particular, the
lotting pattern and road pattern at the east end of the plan (Streets ‘A’ and ‘C’
and associated lotting) may need to be revised to reflect land exchange/sale
agreement between the parties.
Public
Works Facility Master Plan Study to be completed by December 2006
The redevelopment of the Miller site and
corresponding property requirements on Town property will have an impact on the
Town maintenance yard operations.
The Operations Department recently initiated a
two-phase Public Works Facility Master Plan Study. The purpose of the study is to review the
existing Town facility portfolio and identify goals and objectives to be
pursued over the next 20 years. One
option recommends a site of approximately 10 ha (25 acres) in the future, in
the vicinity of the Town’s existing yard maintenance operations [4.5 ha (11.1
acres)] on the west side of
Revision
to proposed industrial blocks required to facilitate future land exchange
The current configuration of Block 8 does not meet
the frontage requirements of the General Industrial (GI) zoning standards in
By-law 177-96. The General Industrial
zone requires a minimum frontage of 60 metres, whereas the proposed Block 8 has
a frontage of approximately 50 metres, and has constrained access to Street
‘A’. In addition, Blocks 6 to 9 inclusive
may also need to be reconfigured in order to facilitate a future land exchange
with the Town to facilitate the construction of a stormwater management pond on
Town land, and the proposed road across Town land (Street ‘A’). This is a condition of draft plan approval
(Appendix A). Details of any land
exchange/sale are to be addressed in the Agreement of Purchase and
Purchase
and Sale Agreement required prior to issuance of draft plan approval by the
Director of
Negotiations with the applicant with respect to a
possible land exchange/sale of Town lands, development phasing and
The Owner will be required to execute an Agreement
of Purchase and Sale (with timing and phasing provisions) satisfactory to the Chief
Administrative Officer and Town Solicitor, which will document the Town and the
Owner’s commitments. It is recommended
that this be required prior to the release of the draft plan for registration, and be reflected in the subdivision
agreement. It is recommended that the
Chief Administrative Officer and the Commissioner of Community and Fire
Services report back to Council on the terms and conditions of the Agreement.
In the event that the Town opts for land exchange, at the Town’s sole discretion, the applicant shall make lands within the plan of subdivision immediately adjacent to the Town works yard available to the Town on an equal ‘acre for acre’ basis, in a condition and configuration acceptable to the Town, and at no cost to the Town. Any land transaction, material relocation, site preparation, soil remediation or other costs relating to lands to be transferred by the applicant to the Town, are to be borne by the applicant.
Traffic
Impact Study to be revised to address Ministry of Transportation
The proposed 407 Transitway and
associated Woodbine Station are planned on the north side of
MTO recently initiated the Environmental Assessment
process for the Highway 407 transitway and this is expected to be completed in
3 years. The Ministry will be requested
to sign off on the proposed intersection locations at
As a condition of draft plan approval, the Owner
will be required to make revisions to the draft plan that may be required to
achieve the recommendations of the Traffic Impact Study.
Development Phasing Plan has been
submitted for review
OPA
146 requires that a Development Phasing Plan be submitted to address the timing
of the comprehensive development of the lands, including the following:
A
preliminary phasing plan has been submitted by the applicant for review. The existing Miller operations are proposed
to be decommissioned and phased out by 2010 and Street ‘A’ is proposed to be
constructed (from
Additional technical supporting
documents are to be submitted
Along
with the studies noted above, the Engineering Department will require the
following technical supporting documentation either prior to, or as a condition
of subdivision approval:
·
Functional Servicing Plan
·
Geotechnical Analysis and/or Soil Stability Study
·
Internal Functional Traffic Design Study
·
Noise Impact Study
·
Erosion and Sediment Control Plan
·
Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) Phase II
·
Environmental Impact Study
·
Environmental Management Plan
·
Conceptual Built Form Master Plan
Preliminary environmental site
screening report prepared as part of Highway 407/Rodick Road Study
The
property was originally used for sand and gravel extraction from the 1950’s to
1970’s and fill was deposited on the property in the late 1970’s. As part of the Highway 407/Rodick Road study,
a preliminary environmental site screening report was prepared by the Town’s
consultants to characterize the site and identify areas of potential
contamination, and to provide recommendations for additional studies/action
plans. According to the study, the majority of the subject property has a
moderate potential for contamination, but there are significant areas along the
easterly portion of the property with a high potential for contamination.
Applicant must demonstrate
environmental condition of site is suitable for the proposed
commercial/industrial uses
Section
46 of the Environmental Protection Act (EPA) requires the Minister’s approval
for use of lands or land covered by water which was previously used for landfilling/waste
disposal. The Town received a letter
from the Ministry of the Environment (MOE) on
In
accordance with the requirements of the MOE and the Town’s Official Plan
policies, the applicant will be required to provide the Town with the following,
prior to final approval of the draft plan of subdivision:
·
Phase II Environmental Site Assessment
·
A complete Remediation Plan
·
Environmental Management Plan (EMP)
·
Record of Site Condition be filed with the Environmental Site Registry
office of the MOE, summarizing the environmental condition of all the lands
·
Environmental clearance letter for any lands to be conveyed to the Town
Staff
will retain a peer review consultant (at the Owner’s cost) to review and
comment on the above noted documents. If
the environmental reports identify environmental conditions that do not warrant
development, the applicant will be required to amend the draft plan, to the
satisfaction of the Town. The Town will
also be requesting appropriate financial securities to ensure that any off-site
contamination is remediated and a monitoring program is provided (Appendix A).
Clearance required from the
The
Toronto and Region Conservation Authority (TRCA) has indicated that if
satisfactory arrangements cannot be made with the Town to locate the proposed
stormwater management pond on Town owned lands on the east side of Rodick Road,
then the following will be required:
This
is addressed in the “red line” revisions and conditions of draft approval. The onus is on the applicant to provide for a
stormwater management pond on – site, or to satisfy the Town as to the terms
of a land exchange/sale to potentially
locate the pond on Town owned lands.
The
TRCA has also requested that the zoning by-law include a Hold (H) provision to
ensure that adequate arrangement have been made to implement the proposed
stormwater management strategy. This
Hold (H) provision has been included in the proposed zoning by-law (Appendix
B).
Clearance required from the
Ministry of Natural Resources
As
indicated earlier, the site contains a former aggregate pit. The Owner will be required to submit
rehabilitation site plans for the former aggregate pit pursuant to the
Aggregate Resources Act, R.S.O., c.A.8., to the satisfaction of the Ministry of
Natural Resources, and the Director of Engineering. This is a condition of
draft plan approval (Appendix A).
An Area Specific Development Charge
By-law has not been completed
An
area specific development charge by-law for the Highway 407/Rodick Road area
has not yet been prepared by Town staff.
The process is in the early stages and a by-law may not be in place
prior to the proposed development moving forward. If this is the case, an agreement with the
owner will be required to ensure that an estimate of the required charges is
paid in advance of the final development charge by-law, prior to registration
of a subdivision agreement (Appendix A).
In addition, the applicant will be required to enter into a Front End
and Credit Agreement for the upfronting of external infrastructure required to
accommodate their development (i.e. stormwater management pond, Rodick
servicing road improvements, etc.).
Conceptual Built Form Master Plan
required
Official
Plan Amendment 146 (
No issues identified at public meeting
A public meeting was held on
FINANCIAL TEMPLATE (Separate Attachment):
Not applicable
As noted above, a portion of the site is
identified as a former landfill/waste disposal site and is a potential area for
historical contamination. The applicant
will be required to provide a number of environmental studies prior to final
approval, to ensure that any concerns are resolved prior to final release of
the plan of subdivision.
Not applicable
ENGAGE 21ST CONSIDERATIONS:
The proposed development promotes a number of key goals set out in “Engage 21st Century Markham” by establishing diverse employment opportunities and efficient use of infrastructure.
BUSINESS UNITS CONSULTED AND AFFECTED:
The requirements of other
municipal departments and external agencies have been incorporated into the
draft plan and recommended conditions of draft plan approval.
RECOMMENDED BY:
___________________________ ____________________________
Valerie
Shuttleworth, M.C.I.P, R.P.P Jim Baird, M.C.I.P, R.P.P
Director,
__________________________
Alan Brown, C.E.T.
Director of Engineering
Figure 1 - Location Map
Figure 2 - Area Context/Zoning
Figure 3 – Aerial Map
Figure 4 – Proposed Draft Plan of Subdivision
Figure 5 – Lands covered by Official Plan 146
Appendix ‘A’ – Conditions of Draft Plan Approval
Appendix ‘B’ – Proposed Zoning By-law