Report to: Budget Sub-Committee                                             Report Date: January 12, 2009

 

 

SUBJECT:                          Fitness Initiation Fees

PREPARED BY:               Colin Service, Manager Planning & Policy, Ext 7543

                                           

 

RECOMMENDATION:

 

That the report entitled Fitness Initiation Fees be received;

 

And that the Town of Markham move toward a formal initiation fee when joining one of the Town operated fitness facilities, consistent with industry standard;

 

And that Council endorse an increase in the one time initiation fee to $90.00 annually, from the current $62.50 per person, representing an increase of approximately $23,061 on an annualized basis;

 

And that Council endorse an increase in the one time initiation fees to $120.00 annually for adult non-resident from the current $26.00 per person, with a projected increase of approximately $2,475 on an annualized basis;

 

And that there is no initiation fee for student membership categories, again consistent with industry standard;

 

And that this initiation fee takes affect March 1, 2009;

 

And that By-law 2002-276, a by-law to impose fees and charges for services or activities provided or done by the Town of Markham, be amended to reflect the new rates;

 

And further that notice to the public be provided in accordance with By-law 2002-275, a by-law to prescribe the form and manner and times for the provision of reasonable notice;

 

And that Staff be authorized and directed to do all things necessary to give effect to this resolution.

 

PURPOSE:

The purpose of this report is to find alternative revenue generating opportunities as part of the E3 initiative.  As well, revenue generated will be utilized in offsetting increase in part time wages that will occur in moving towards a formalized part time wage grid.

 

BACKGROUND:

Currently, new members are paying a higher fee when joining one of our fitness facilities.  The fees are as follows:

 

Category

New Member Fee

Renewal Member Fee

Price Difference

Adult Resident

$544.50

$482.00

$62.50

Spousal

$1,037.00

$859.00

$178.00

Senior Citizen (65+)

$377.50

$335.50

$42.00

Adult Non Resident

$570.50

$544.50

$26.00

Spousal Non Resident

$1089.50

$932.50

$157.00

Student

$398.50

$398.50

$0

 

Once a member has completed their first year of membership, the fee for all subsequent years is the Renewal Member Fee.  It should be noted that in promotional materials the additional fee for new members will be separately noted as an initiation fee.

 

When looking at single adult memberships (the primary financial driver for fitness facilities), please note the following comparison in pricing for annual fees excluding any form of initiation fee:

 

Markham

Vaughan

Mississauga

YMCA

Good Life

$482.00

$542.00

$418.08

$559.68

$767.00

 

It is difficult to compare initiation fees within the fitness industry as this fee fluctuates dramatically with promotions for the particular club.  However, below is a comparison of the average of initiation fees for the particular club:

 

Markham

Vaughan

Mississauga

YMCA

Good Life

$62.50

$75.00

$100.00

$75.00

$100.00

 

It should be noted that a comprehensive fitness assessment and personalized program development is included with the purchase of each new membership at a Town of Markham facility.  This is not typical within the industry.

 

OPTIONS/ DISCUSSION:

An increase to a consistent initiation fee of $90 for resident and $120 for non residents annually would not impact existing users of the fitness centres.  Existing members will continue to pay the Renewal Member Fee.

 

Recommended initiation fees are well within industry standards.  It is acceptable within industry standard and allowed by the Consumer Protection Act to charge an initiation fee of up to 25% of annual cost of membership.  Proposed initiation fees on average is 20% of the annual cost of membership.

 

We are also recommending a change in policy to increase fees to non-resident adults.  It should be noted that the base annual membership fee is already significantly higher for non residents.  Increasing the initiation fee will ensure consistency with the initiation fee and base annual fee.  Consistently other municipalities in Ontario charge a higher base annual fee and initiation fee for non residents.

 

Notice of fee increases will be provided on Town Website and Town page of local Markham Newspapers.

 


 

FINANCIAL CONSIDERATIONS AND TEMPLATE:

With proposed initiation fees, the structure would look as follows:

 

Category

New Member Fee

Renewal Member Fee

Price Difference

Adult Resident

$572.00

$482.00

$90.00

Spousal

$1,039.00

$859.00

$180.00

Adult Non Resident

$664.50

$544.50

$120.00

Spousal Non Resident

$1172.50

$932.50

$240.00

 

As stated previously, this fee increase will only impact new members joining in 2009 and forward.  Consequently, all existing members are unaffected by this change.  Seniors and Students were not included in the above table as no change is recommended to these fees at this time. The fee increase for new members is represented in the following table: 

 

 

Category

Existing New Member Fee

Proposed New Member Fee

Price Difference

Adult Resident

$544.50

$572.00

$27.50

Spousal

$1,037.00

$1039.00

$2.00

Senior Citizen (65+)

$377.50

$377.50

$0

Adult Non Resident

$570.50

$664.50

$94.00

Spousal Non Resident

$1089.50

$1172.50

$83.00

Student

$398.50

$398.50

$0

 

 

This proposed change in initiation fee will positively impact revenue as follows:

 

 

Category

# of New Members Anticipated

Current Initiation Fee

Total Current Revenue

Proposed New Initiation Fee

Proposed New Revenue

Revenue Improvement

Adult Resident

834

$62.50

$52,125

$90.00

$75,060

$22,935

Spousal

63

$178.00

$11,214

$180.00

$11,340

$126

Adult Non Resident

25

$26.00

$650

$120.00

$3,125

$2,475

Spousal Non Resident

0

$157.00

$0

$240.00

$0

$0

Total Revenue Improvement in 2009

$25,536

 

As demonstrated in the above table, there is a projected positive revenue impact of approximately $25,536 on annualized basis while providing no financial implications for existing members. 

 

 

 

HUMAN RESOURCES CONSIDERATIONS

Not applicable

 

ALIGNMENT WITH STRATEGIC PRIORITIES

This proposal aligns with corporate strategic priority of parks, recreation, culture and library master plan/public safety by continuing to provide opportunity for youth by having no initiation fee for students.

 

BUSINESS UNITS CONSULTED AND AFFECTED

Finance.

 

RECOMMENDED

                                 

 

 

 

 

                            BY:    ________________________          ________________________

                                      Glen Taylor                                        Brenda Librecz

                                      Acting Director of                               Commissioner,

                                      Recreation Services                                    Community & Fire Services

 

Q:\Recreation\REPORTS\Fitness Initiation Fees.doc